The Bullroarer - Friday 29th August 2008

3News - Business community says ETS damaging to economy

Business New Zealand is labelling the emissions trading bill badly thought out and economically damaging.

Under the scheme, that passed its second reading yesterday, companies which exceed their greenhouse gas emission limits will have to buy credits from others that are under the limit.

ABC - LNP urges permanent shale oil mining ban

The Liberal-National Party (LNP) is calling on the Queensland Government to place a life long ban on shale oil mining.

The State Government placed a 20 year ban on mining the McFarlane Deposit, south of Proserpine in the state's north on Sunday, quashing Queensland Energy Resources hopes of extracting 1.6 billion barrels of oil in the next 40 years.

Canberra Times - Carbon spike hits Kyoto gas pledge

Australia's fossil fuel emissions are growing more than four times faster than figures quoted by the Federal Government, placing Australia's Kyoto target at risk.

Figures published online yesterday by one of the world's top authorities on greenhouse emissions shows Australia's total fossil fuel emissions jumped by 8.3 per cent from 93 million tonnes in 2004 to just over 100 million tonnes in 2005.

The Australian - AGL Energy sells windfarm for $59 million

AGL Energy has sold its Hallet 2 wind farm, which is under construction in South Australia, to Energy Infrastructure Trust (EIT) for $59 million.

EIT is managed by ANZ offshoot ANZ Infrastructure Services.

NZ Herald - Tui oil sparks profit surge at NZOG - $97.2m for the year

New Zealand Oil & Gas has posted a surge in full year net profit to $97.2 million on the back of production from the Tui oilfields off the Taranaki coast.

"This outstanding result was built on a combination of high oil prices and higher than expected production from Tui," NZOG said today.

The Australian - Flawed energy policy shows O'Farrell up

NSW Liberal Party leader Barry O'Farrell's decision to block planned energy privatisation has handed more negotiating power to NSW trade unions, threatened the state's fragile economy and cast serious doubt on his own ability to govern.

In short, it is a case of politics for politics' sake at its very worst.

The Australian - Origin Energy swears by coal gas as net rises 13pc

AS shareholders wait for Origin Energy to select a partner to develop its Queensland coal seam gas reserves, the takeover target yesterday boosted full-year net profit by 13 per cent to a record $517 million on a strong performance from its retail business.

NZ Herald - Stock takes: Air New Zealand salaries in tailspin

There's only so much an airline can do about the price of jet fuel but Fyfe says it's only fair that as the business performance goes down, so does pay.

Waikato Times - Dismay at wind farm move

Councils are opposed to Government plans to fast-track Contact Energy's application to build a gigantic $1 billion wind farm along the isolated Te Akau coast.

Environment Minister Trevor Mallard this week announced his intention to "call in" the 180turbine Hauauru ma Raki wind farm planned for construction between Te Akau and Port Waikato.

In deeming the project to be of national significance, Mr Mallard has used his ministerial intervention powers to direct that the resource consent process be referred to a board of inquiry, rather than be heard by Environment Waikato, Waikato District Council, and Franklin District Council.

Scoop.co.nz - Big electricity savings

Christchurch City Council is on track for huge electricity savings this year thanks to both human and mechanical initiatives at its Civic Offices in Tuam Street.

Council energy analyst Yvonne Gilmore says savings of about $25,000 a year were already being made at the Civic Offices thanks to the efforts of the Council's Energy Team.

"By the end of this winter this is set to rise by potentially another $15,000 over and above existing savings. This is an amazing achievement."

The Australian - NZ Oil & Gas forecast strong outlook

NEW Zealand Oil and Gas has recorded a sharp jump in annual profit, boosted by production at the Tui oil field and record oil prices.

The New Zealand-based gas and oil exploration company (ASX: NZO) said net profit for the full year to June 30 was $NZ97.2 million ($79.2 million), up from $NZ6.8 million a year earlier.

Daily Telegraph - Sydney transport a rail embarrassment

HERE'S proof that Sydney's rail network is a laughing stock when compared with its global peers.

Experts have compared Sydney's public transport infrastructure with major cities including New York, Paris and Barcelona - and the embarrassing results speak for themselves.

The special report, obtained by The Daily Telegraph, reveals the international cities have as much as eight times the length of track that Sydney does.

The Age - Market-based scheme key to carbon crisis

But implementing such an approach faces a built-in handicap from day one.

THERE is no such thing as a pure market. In the debate over the best way to tackle climate change there seems to be universal agreement that market-based measures, such as emissions trading, are the preferred option of Australian industry.

Market-based mechanisms are seen as the most efficient way to solve our escalating emissions problem, with all other approaches described as distortions of an otherwise perfectly functioning, unencumbered market.

Otago Daily Times - Dunedin turns to public transport

More Dunedin commuters are shunning cars in favour of buses as rising fuel prices bite.

Bus patronage has risen dramatically and the number of cars on the road has dropped as Dunedin workers mirror a national trend and leave their cars at home.

However, locals may be leaving their northern counterparts in the dust.

A-Z o Build - Turnkey Solution for Solar Power From Solar Manufacturer Day4 Energy

Day4 Energy Inc., a leading manufacturer of high performance, cost-effective solar electric modules, today announced the strategic partnership with CERTUS Life Cycle AG (CLC) to finance photovoltaic (PV) power generation projects in Europe with a specific focus on the expanding Italian market. Under the arrangement Day4 Energy will leverage its industry leading solar module technology and extensive network of system integration partners to develop turnkey PV power generation projects commissioned and funded by CLC.

The Australian - Transport sector airs concerns on carbon

DOMESTIC tourism and Australian airlines would be hard hit as more Australians chose to fly overseas on foreign carriers for their holidays rather than pay domestic airfares inflated by the impact of the Government's proposed emissions trading regime.

Climate Change Minister Penny Wong and Transport Minister Anthony Albanese heard these concerns at a special meeting with the transport industry yesterday, where the aviation, shipping and railway sectors complained that the Government's scheme would put them at a competitive disadvantage.

I should open the Jaded Greenie's Translation Service.

"Business New Zealand is labelling the emissions trading bill badly thought out and economically damaging."

Translation: "Give us more money."

"NSW Liberal Party leader Barry O'Farrell's decision to block planned energy privatisation has handed more negotiating power to NSW trade unions, threatened the state's fragile economy and cast serious doubt on his own ability to govern."

Translation: "Poopyhead! Why didn't you vote the way our paper's advertisers wanted you to?!"

"Councils are opposed to Government plans to fast-track Contact Energy's application to build a gigantic $1 billion wind farm along the isolated Te Akau coast."

Translation: "Not in my backyard!"

"Climate Change Minister Penny Wong and Transport Minister Anthony Albanese heard these concerns at a special meeting with the transport industry yesterday, where the aviation, shipping and railway sectors complained that the Government's [emissions trading] scheme would put them at a competitive disadvantage."

Translation: "Give us more money."

Sigh.

Yup, that's what I thought it probably said. The Kiwi translation looks pretty much like the Aussie translation, only in Aussie-land there would also have been 7 mutually-contradictory versions of the opposition's alternative "plan" delivered by at least 5 different wanna-be opposition leaders. Ohhh.... and 1 fluffy, feel-good, motherhood statement from our Prime Minister, and 3 contradictory statements from the real opposition leader who ties himself in knots in his attempt to say precisely the opposite of whatever the Prime Minister says, while also trying to keep the various factions within his own party happy and simultaneously look credible to the voting public.

*Sigh*

Why did poopyhead vote against privatising the power stations anyway ?

I don't actually follow the NSW Libs because they are such an ineffectual rabble I figure its not worth wasting my attention on them - is this some tactical manouevre or a deep-seated belief in public ownership of some infrastructure assets ?

Poopyhead was following the old political maxim: "If your enemy is drowning, throw him an anvil"...

There was an excellent interview on the ABC last night, where Quentin Dempster pointed out that Poopyhead was contradicting just about every policy statement that the Liberal Party has made about privatising electricity. Poopyhead wasn't troubled - winners are grinners!
;-)

This is all going to be a massive mess. Personally, I think we need the Government to grab hold of the electricity industry with both hands and build a sustainable future. That's what governments are for, to look into the future and take the big decisions that are "uneconomic" in conventional private industry terms, but have huge social benefits. (Before anyone criticises this logic, have a think about the "profitability" of the Defence Forces...)

Sadly the Iemma govt has been trying to jettison the problem and desperately hope that someone in private industry can fix it. (Obviously none of the NSW ministers have been on a "study tour" to another of the world's few coal-rich states, but ironically suffering major blackouts: South Africa.)

Many of the future power sources are available in abundance in lucky NSW (solar, wind, wave, geothermal, biomass/char, and even pumped water storage) but an innovative approach is needed right now. 2012 and the Peak Oil Slope is coming...

We're going to regret the wasted time and missed opportunities in a big way in a few years' time.

About the only upside is that we may get rid of Michael Costa...

The cartoon does point out one issue in Iemma and Costa's favour (at least as per their original plan) - they may have been able to offload a whole lot of uncompetitive coal fired kit off onto the private sector - repeating Jeff Kennett's financial wizardry on behalf of Victoria.

Instead the likely outcome is that NSW taxpayers will be lumbered with an asset that drops dramatically in value as the ETS starts to bite...

This is a comment on the Age and its article about the ETS.

Don't get me wrong - I am all in favour of pricing carbon. I just think the governments proposed ETS is a crock. MBI's (Market Based Instruments) have their good points - they do help shift resources to the most efficient schemes and producers for instance. However on balance, for carbon, I think it is very much a second best.

Of course governments (politicians) love MBI's. They are a whole new way of handing out goodies to their mates without any of the downside (cost) appearing in the national accounts. However as most economists will point out this ETS is in effect a tax. It is a whole new cost that will be imposed on the Australian economy, on top of the massive taxation funded cost that our bloated system of government already costs us.

A far better alternative would have been a carbon tax. It could have been introduced as a dollar for dollar alternative for income tax. Instead of bleating on about his beloved working families KRudd could actually have done something concrete to help them by removing income taxes from the bottom up. He could have taken huge swathes of people out of the income tax net all together. Or he could have really helped working families by allowing husbands and wives to declare joint incomes. He could have done a lot of good stuff. But he has thrown the opportunity away.

A carbon tax would be certain, simple and cheap to raise. Charged by grade of coal, oil or gas at the well, pit head or on import it would have automatically flowed through the entire economy. Most of the efficiencies achievable under MBI's would be encouraged anyway. As a dollar for dollar alternative to income tax there would be no new burden on the economy (thus at a stroke disarming the international competitiveness lobby).

Instead the ETS is really a huge new tax on the economy. It is enormously complex, will require expensive policing (to ensure businesses do not exceed their caps), will not deliver a certain price, needs complex accounting and is an open barn door for graft by our shonky politicians. It is a crock.

You are correct,SailDog.I am cynical enough to believe that the ETS "crock" is quite deliberate.

Essentially it is stupidity within corruption within stupidity.We need a cull in the political and business herd but I don't see much hope in any of the other potential breeding stock.